Analysts Rishab Bailey and Prapasiri “Nan” Suttisome warn that the rollout of fifth- and sixth-generation networks could face considerable delays in countries that have signed reciprocal trade agreements with the United States. Their analysis first appeared on Public Citizen and EngageMedia, and Global Voices later published an edited version.

Advertisement

Replacing Chinese equipment, a costly and slow task

The core of the argument is practical. According to the authors, Western firms may not be able to fill, in time, at an affordable price and with the necessary volume, the gap that the exit of Chinese manufacturers would leave. As an example, they point to Washington's own experience: according to reports cited in the analysis, between 2019 and 2024 only 12% of the Chinese equipment installed in the United States was removed.

Europe has run into similar obstacles. The authors recall that the European Commission found that Chinese technology can cost up to 60% or 70% less than that of Western manufacturers. Separately, various estimates calculate that replacing it across all sectors of the European Union could cost up to 430 billion dollars.

The clause in question

Since February 2025, Washington has concluded these pacts with Argentina, Bangladesh, Cambodia, Ecuador, El Salvador, Guatemala, Indonesia, Jordan, Malaysia and Taiwan. According to the analysis, most of them contain a provision under which the signatories agree not to contract technology providers that endanger the security of 5G and 6G networks, communications satellites or submarine cables. In the cases of El Salvador, Guatemala, Indonesia and Malaysia, they must also seek the US view on which companies meet that criterion.

In Bailey and Suttisome's view, the measure basically allows Washington to shut out Huawei and ZTE if it so decides, with a possible advantage for US companies such as CISCO and Hewlett Packard.

Countries with limited connectivity

The analysis stresses that many signatories are low-resource economies. Internet penetration stands at around 53.4% in Bangladesh, 60.2% in Guatemala, 66.5% in El Salvador, 68.5% in Cambodia and 72.8% in Indonesia. In education, more than 100,000 Indonesian schools lack internet, about 12% of Guatemalan schools also have none, and in Cambodia only 22% of schools have working computers. Worldwide, one in three people lacks a reliable connection, according to the authors.

Advertisement

That gap has largely been filled by China, which in many developing countries has offered soft loans through the Digital Silk Road, with interest rates below market levels and conditional on using Chinese suppliers. The authors acknowledge that depending on them entails risks, such as possible foreign surveillance or a "kill switch" in the equipment.

The alternative they propose

Bailey and Suttisome propose that trade treaties promote a global hardware market open to competition, in which low- and middle-income countries choose among different suppliers and each government decides based on its technical needs, its budget and its security. Among the priorities they cite are guaranteeing technology transfers that strengthen local capacity, supporting decentralized networks able to use more domestic equipment, and improving global financing.

Sources