A County Durham chemical company has been fined £103,850 after an Environment Agency prosecution over liquid waste containing phenol, a toxic chemical, that reached open ground at its plant. Prefere Resins UK Ltd operates on Heighington Lane in the Aycliffe Industrial Park, Newton Aycliffe. It was sentenced at Newton Aycliffe Magistrates' Court on Friday 13 November. The court also ordered it to pay £18,784.61 to cover costs and a victim surcharge.
Three breaches of one permit
The firm makes and sells phenol-based products under an environmental permit, EPR/XP3635ET, issued by the agency. It pleaded guilty on 16 June to three offences, all covering 17 July 2024 to 20 July 2024. According to the agency's summary of the charges, the first concerned Condition 3.1.1: waste liquid went onto land from a point that the permit does not list as an approved emission source. The other two fell under Condition 1.1.1(a), which requires the operator to follow a written management system that identifies and minimises pollution risks. One of these counts related to draining and flushing a phenol recovery unit. The other related to keeping flammable materials in bunded areas.
Damage to the ground
The agency said soil tests found phenol at environmentally harmful levels. One laboratory recorded up to 3,640mg/kg and a second up to 10,000mg/kg. Satellite pictures and earlier records established that the ground had been uncontaminated before, the agency said.
The court heard that officers arrived unannounced in July 2024, during a maintenance shutdown of part of the plant. They found about 70m² of unsurfaced ground that was scorched, brown and lifeless, damp to walk on and smelling of chemicals. Staff had been draining and flushing the phenol recovery column unit before the maintenance work. The open end of a flexible hose fitted to that unit lay on the damaged patch.
The agency said it identified no harm to groundwater. However, the site lies inside a groundwater protection zone, so releasing pollutants onto land carried a contamination risk.
Missing procedures and risky storage
The company's new Safety, Health and Environment Manager told officers he had pinpointed numerous gaps in the site's procedures. Inspectors found that no written method existed for cleaning the pump located at the bottom of the recovery unit.
They also found incompatible chemicals placed side by side. Some containers were positioned so that any leak could spill beyond the bund. In one example, the agency said, a container of waste electrical equipment stood beside drums of acetone, a highly flammable liquid. The agency warned that accidental mixing could lead to fire, an explosion or toxic gases.
Response and oversight
According to the Environment Agency, the company later carried out remediation to remove the contamination and has revised its operating procedures. The site is an upper tier Control of Major Accident Hazards (COMAH) site, overseen jointly by the agency and the Health and Safety Executive.
Gary Wallace, the agency's Area Environment Manager, said firms handling dangerous chemicals are responsible for managing them safely. He added that Prefere had not run its site properly, which put the environment at risk. "This court result should send out a message to others that we will always take action where companies fall short of the required standards," he said.


