Professor William Webster, the Biometrics and Surveillance Camera Commissioner, has given qualified support to the government's plans for regulating facial recognition. He said the official consultation response points in a direction he strongly endorses but leaves several important matters unresolved.

Advertisement

In a statement on GOV.UK, Webster said he would wait for the Police Reform Bill to reach Parliament before seeing the complete proposals. He described the coming law as a chance that arrives only once in a generation to set binding rules and safeguards. He said it is needed urgently because facial recognition is spreading fast across society.

Questions still open

According to the commissioner, the response does not yet explain:

  • how governance, accountability and oversight will be divided between primary legislation and the planned statutory code of practice;
  • what tests of necessity and proportionality will involve;
  • who will judge whether particular technologies are effective and acceptable;
  • what meaningful oversight will mean in practice;
  • where national technical and operational standards will come from;
  • how rules will be enforced on commercial users;
  • whether the new oversight body will get sufficient resources.

He also asked for more information on whether that body's powers, funding and specialist expertise will be enough for audit and compliance work. Close coordination with other regulators would be vital, he said, so that oversight neither overlaps nor leaves blind spots.

Why safeguards matter

Webster called live facial recognition and other biometric surveillance intrusive. He argued that these tools clash with core human rights, among them privacy, peaceful assembly, free expression and freedom of movement. The government's response recognises that such rights could be interfered with, he noted, and in his view clear law and effective safeguards are needed to reduce that risk.

He also pointed to uneven policing. Forces have handled the recent live deployments he has watched in different ways, he said, and a legal framework could encourage consistent adherence to national standards, building on the Home Secretary's Surveillance Camera Code of Practice. Webster expects facial recognition to be built increasingly into existing camera networks, body-worn video and drones, and said AI-powered video analytics will dramatically expand what conventional cameras can do. For that reason, he said, Parliament must be able to bring further technologies within the framework later.

Advertisement

Elements he welcomed

Webster said he was pleased that the proposals for a new oversight body say it will hold compliance powers, something he had sought, together with audit and inspection powers, in his own consultation submission. He also welcomed plans to cover public services beyond policing, to publish a new statutory code of practice and to produce a similar code for businesses. A single oversight body, he said, should simplify what he called a cluttered regulatory landscape. According to Webster, the response aims to build on his office's existing work and on principles in the Protection of Freedoms Act 2012.

Sources