Soldiers in Indonesia who commit crimes could end up before civilian judges after the country's Constitutional Court gave legislators two years to amend the 1997 Military Justice Law. If the deadline passes without changes, the law becomes invalid, Global Voices reported. The ruling was issued on October 15 and drew praise from human rights groups.

Advertisement

Why the ruling matters

At the centre of the dispute is Article 9. According to Global Voices, it places active-duty members of the Indonesian National Armed Forces under the military justice system alone, covering not only military offences but also ordinary crimes and human rights violations.

Campaigners have long pressed for change. They say they have documented failures by military courts to investigate and prosecute grave abuses by soldiers, and they object that military judges are themselves serving soldiers. Proceedings, they add, often unfold inside the chain of command and out of public sight.

Global Voices describes the statute as a legacy of the New Order, the period of Suharto's rule from 1966 to his resignation in 1998, during which he leaned on the military to hold power.

Reactions from rights groups

KontraS, an Indonesian human rights group, welcomed the decision. It said one of its employees was the target of an acid attack by a group of soldiers, and that under the new ruling such a case could be heard in a public court. In its statement, the group said the decision ends a gap in the law that had long been viewed as sheltering soldiers from being held to account.

Human Rights Watch said changing the statute would advance a decades-old push to make the armed forces professional and credible, with soldiers answerable for serious abuses. Free Press Unlimited called the decision a victory against impunity and urged lawmakers to act promptly.

Advertisement

Indonesian and international civil society groups want legislators to open the reform with consultations involving the public and a variety of stakeholders, according to Global Voices.

What was argued in court

Petitioners included Eva Meliani Pasaribu. Global Voices reports that her father, Tribrata TV journalist Rico Sempurna Pasaribu, was killed in June 2024 following his reporting on gambling activity in which a senior military officer was allegedly implicated. The armed forces examined the claim in private and rejected it, citing insufficient evidence, according to the same account.

Ibnu Syamsu Hidayat, legal counsel for the petition, told the court that letting military jurisdiction override the general judiciary clashes with constitutional democracy. He said the law's broad wording has been read to let military courts handle cases such as corruption, traffic offences, domestic violence and narcotics.

Senior officers defended the arrangement. Marshal H. Haris Haryanto of the Ministry of Defense said military courts are built to weigh the nature of soldiers' conduct alongside national defence interests. General Agus Subiyanto, commander of the armed forces, argued the petition reflected an incomplete grasp of how military law works, and said military judges enjoy constitutionally guaranteed independence and technical supervision by the Supreme Court.

Legal expert Al Araf told the court the law was drafted under an "authoritarian political regime". Another expert, Zainal Arifin Mochtar, argued it needed revision to bring it in line with democratic principles.

Concerns about the wider picture

Activists say continued public scrutiny is essential, according to Global Voices, which notes that President Prabowo Subianto was a general removed from the armed forces over human rights abuses. Since taking office in 2024, the outlet adds, he has widened the part the military plays in running civilian affairs.

Sources